On this page

The short answer

  1. Read the dispute reason on the notice — not the reason you wish it were.
  2. Pick the smallest set of records that directly answer that reason.
  3. Label each file for the claim it supports.
  4. Leave out policies, screenshots, and other orders that do not speak to this claim.

Match the record to the reason

If the notice reason and your files disagree, change the files.
If the claim isSubmit records that showA weak substitute
Not received / item not receivedThis order was delivered, picked up, accessed, or performedRefund policy, unrelated invoices
Not as described / defectiveWhat was advertised versus what was delivered, plus any remedyTracking that only proves a box arrived
Unauthorized / fraudThe legitimate cardholder authorized or received this purchaseA general statement that you "know" the customer
DuplicateTwo charges are two orders, or the extra one was reversedDelivery photos of one order
Credit not processedThe refund posted, or why it was not dueOutbound tracking for the original shipment
Subscription cancelledTerms accepted, cancel request, charge date, usage in the billed periodA shipping label

Rank what you already have

  1. 01
    Direct proof

    Delivery scan with full address, refund ID, two distinct invoices, listing versus delivered item.

  2. 02
    Customer acknowledgment

    A message about this shipment or order — not a newsletter open.

  3. 03
    Policy shown before purchase

    Only if the reason is about policy, and only the relevant section.

  4. 04
    Context

    AVS, prior orders, account history — helpful when they support direct proof, not when they replace it.

Organize before you upload

A reviewer should find the answer without hunting. Use a short cover position, an exhibit index, and labeled files. See how to make a chargeback response packet and what not to submit.

Pick the guide for this notice