On this page

Three case types that should not be treated as synonyms

The case screen and its requested action are authoritative if the wording differs.
What you seeWho handles the decisionWhat the merchant should do first
PayPal dispute / inquiryBuyer and merchant communicate; PayPal provides the Resolution Center channelRead the buyer's message, check the transaction, and decide whether to resolve, make an offer, or escalate
PayPal claimPayPal reviews the evidence and decides the internal caseRead PayPal's evidence request and response deadline before assembling files
External card chargebackThe buyer's bank or card issuer decides; PayPal relays the responseRespond to the PayPal case with the evidence requested for the issuer review

Your first ten minutes with the case

  1. 01
    Read the case header before the buyer's narrative

    Capture the case ID, transaction ID, case type, reason, status, amount, requested action, and deadline. A familiar phrase can still sit inside a different process.

  2. 02
    Open Transaction Details

    Confirm what was paid, the buyer and delivery information PayPal shows, the item or service sold, and whether the transaction is marked eligible or partially eligible for Seller Protection.

  3. 03
    Preserve the records before systems change

    Save the order as sold, tracking history, delivery or access logs, customer messages, refund activity, and the policy or scope accepted at purchase.

  4. 04
    Match the response to PayPal's fields

    If the case asks for tracking, provide verifiable tracking—not a general shipping policy. If it asks about description, show what was promised and what was delivered.

Evidence changes with the reason

Item not received

Connect this transaction to fulfillment: carrier and tracking, delivered status and date, destination match, signature or receipt where available, or a service/digital access record. Add any refund or replacement record.

Significantly not as described

Put the listing, invoice, scope, condition, or contract from the time of sale next to records of what was delivered. Include the buyer's specific complaint and the return, repair, replacement, or refund response.

Unauthorized transaction

Keep the payment and fulfillment chain together. Use the transaction details, shipment or delivery record, digital access or service completion record, and relevant account or customer history you can document.

Duplicate, amount, cancellation, or missing credit

Compare transaction IDs, timestamps, amounts, authorization or cancellation records, and refund IDs. Make it possible to see which payment each document belongs to.

PayPal's Disputes API evidence reference is useful for understanding current reason categories, but an API enum is not guaranteed to be the exact label or set of fields in your account. The live case request wins. For deeper record checklists, use the chargeback reason library and evidence library.

Sealed cardboard shipping box with packing tape and scissors on a dark wooden table
Merchant fulfillment is physical work: sealed cartons, labels, and a clear packing trail.Photo: Kaboompics / Pexels

Make one transaction story easy to verify

A clear PayPal response

  • Starts with the case reason. The first sentence says what the buyer claims and what the merchant's records establish.
  • Uses a short timeline. Payment, fulfillment, buyer contact, remedy, and dispute dates appear in order.
  • Labels each attachment. The reviewer can connect tracking, listing, conversation, or refund proof to one stated fact.

A difficult review

  • Uploads an account dump. Unrelated payments and long threads make the relevant record harder to find.
  • Treats policy as proof. A shipping policy does not prove delivery; a return policy does not prove the item matched its description.
  • Claims Seller Protection without checking. Eligibility depends on the transaction, case type, market, and current policy—not the existence of tracking alone.

Seller Protection is an eligibility review, not another name for evidence

For a US account, check the live Seller Protection terms and the transaction's eligibility status. Current US terms require timely responses and, for covered physical-goods cases, proof tied to the address on Transaction Details. They describe separate requirements for intangible goods. Other markets and account arrangements can differ.

Check before relying on protection

  • Is the transaction marked eligible or partially eligible where the policy requires it?
  • Does the case type fall within the current protection terms?
  • For shipped goods, does the carrier record match the address PayPal shows for the transaction?
  • For digital goods or services, do your records show delivery, access, or completion in the way the current policy requires?
  • Have you answered every PayPal request by the deadline displayed in the case?

Use the deadline on the case, not a remembered PayPal number

  1. Internal dispute

    PayPal's current documentation describes an inquiry period of up to 20 days for buyer and merchant to resolve or escalate. That is a lifecycle window, not a promise that every merchant evidence request is due in 20 days.

  2. Claim or information request

    The case status and PayPal message determine what action is available and when it is due. A waiting-for-seller-response status can require evidence, acceptance, or a return acknowledgment.

  3. External chargeback

    Card-network and issuer timing sits behind PayPal's request. Use the deadline PayPal displays; do not substitute a Visa, Mastercard, or general chargeback window from another case.

Where the response actually goes

  1. 01
    Sign in to PayPal and open the Resolution Center

    Select the case that needs action. Confirm you are responding to the right transaction and current case status.

  2. 02
    Choose the action PayPal offers

    Depending on the stage, that may be a message or offer, accepting the claim, providing evidence, acknowledging a return, or another case-specific action.

  3. 03
    Enter facts and attach the requested records

    Use the case form's current fields and file rules. Keep a copy of the exact response and confirmation you submitted.

What Zocuments does—and does not do—for a PayPal case

Zocuments canZocuments cannot
Help map order, tracking, payment, communication, and refund records to a dispute reasonConnect to PayPal, read the case, or determine Seller Protection eligibility
Create a browser-local PDF packet with a cover, evidence index, and labeled exhibitsSubmit a dispute response, message the buyer, accept a claim, or appeal a decision
Give the merchant a cleaner record set to use in the PayPal workflowGuarantee that PayPal or a card issuer accepts the files or decides in the merchant's favor

Zocuments is independent of PayPal. Review the packet, then transfer or upload the useful facts and records through the action available in the actual PayPal case.